Original Stories Fan Fiction ❯ Straight Guy Sex? ❯ Getting Lucky ( Chapter 5 )

Warning: This chapter contains strong sexual content of a homosexual nature andadult language.

-o-o-o-o-

Chapter 5: Getting Lucky

Kellen was still stiff when he arrived at school on Monday. He contrived to be late so he would have an excuse to get a ride from his mom instead of walking. He was limping to his first class when a girl stepped up beside him and caught his arm.

“Hey, Kellen! How was your weekend?” she gushed brightly.

“It was fine. I didn't do much.” He glanced at her in faint surprise. Her name was Karin, but for the life of him, he couldn't remember her last name. “How was yours?”

“Great! We had a party at my house. It was a blast!” She rattled on about the party but Kellen only half listened. He wasn't quite sure why she was talking to him. They knew each other, but she wasn't someone he would have thought of as a friend. “So anyway,” Karin continued, “would you like to come to my house after school? We have some great leftovers from the party and I just got the new DDR game.”

Kellen was flabbergasted. His first impulse was to ask “Why are you asking me?” but he stopped himself before the words came out. Instead, he said, “I have swim practice after school.”

“So drop by after swimming.” She lifted her eyebrows at him. “I'm sure I can be as entertaining as Zach!” Kellen stopped in his tracks, stunned, as Karin skipped away. “See you later!” she called over her shoulder.

Kellen shook himself out of his stasis and continued to class, but his thoughts were in turmoil. If he went to Zach's house instead of Karin's, it would be all over the school in no time. He wondered if she was really interested in him or if it was just a test. And if it was just a test, would she go all the way if he did come over? Zach or Karin? Who would he rather see? The ache in his backside reminded him eloquently of just what Zach could do for him. Could Karin make him feel as good? And what would Zach think if he spent time with someone else? He knew Zach was seeing other guys, so would it matter that much if he spent time with a girl?

He didn't try to speak to Zach in econ class, but he ran into him outside the locker room on the way to their swimming class.

“Hey Zach. How's it hanging?”

“An inch shorter, I think,” Zach said with a faint grin. “You're an animal.”

Kellen returned his grin, but he felt awkward. He wasn't sure how to approach Zach about the afternoon. He was about to say something when several guys from the swim team came out of the locker room, pushing roughly past him and Zach. Kellen frowned. “What's going on?”

“Class is cancelled,” someone responded. “Practice is cancelled, too. Coach had an emergency.”

“What happened?”

“Dunno.”

Kellen stopped and glanced at Zach.

Zach shrugged. “I hope nothing bad happened. But I can use the free time. My mom wants me to do some shopping.”

“You're busy this afternoon?”

“Yeah,” Zach nodded. “I was going to tell you in swim class.” He lowered his voice, although no one was close enough to overhear them. “I would think you'd be too sore to see each other today anyway.”

“You'd think,” Kellen smirked. “Will you be free tomorrow?”

“Should be.”

“Ok. So tomorrow afternoon…?”

Zach nodded. “That should work. See you then.”

Kellen watched Zach walk away, wondering why he felt guilty for not mentioning Karin. But now he had no excuse not to go to see her. He went back to his locker to get his books and went to the library to finish his homework so he wouldn't have to take it home. He ran into Karin when he was returning to his locker at the end of the period.

“Hi Kellen!” Karin chirped. “I heard swim practice was cancelled.” She grinned at him suggestively. “Feel like walking home with me?”

“Sure. I just finished my homework.”

She looped her arm through his with an excited squeal. “You did? You must be smart. Maybe you can help me with mine. I'll give you a nice reward.” She lifted her eyebrows at him and her grin widened.

“That isn't necessary…” Kellen began, but Karin interrupted him.

“Don't say that until you find out what I'm offering,” she said cheerfully.

Karin lived in more or less the opposite direction from school than Zach and Kellen, but her house was a lot closer. They arrived at the small cottage-style home after only a quick ten minute stroll.

“Is anyone home?” Kellen asked as they stepped inside.

“No. I live with my mother and she works. My brother is away at college. My room's down here.” She led the way down a short hallway that opened off the left side of the entryway. Her room was on the back of the house just past the bathroom. “My house is kind of small,” Karin said as she dropped her backpack and purse just inside the door of her bedroom. “Dad didn't leave Mom much after the divorce. We used to live in a big house near where you live. We moved here after the divorce because Mom didn't want to make us change schools.”

“That was nice of her.”

“I guess. It would have been nicer if they hadn't gotten divorced. But I don't miss them arguing all the time.” She sank down on the bed and smiled. “Why don't you sit down?”

Kellen glanced around quickly. There was a small secretary chair in front of her desk, but it was pretty obvious she expected him to sit beside her on the bed. He dropped his backpack beside hers and joined her on the bed. “Did you mean it when you said you wanted me to help you with your homework?”

She shook her head slowly with a wide smile. Then she leaned forward and planted a kiss firmly on his lips. “I think we should get to know each other better. You aren't really involved with Zach Kirby, are you?”

Rather than answer the question, Kellen slipped his hand behind her neck and pulled her close for another kiss. It wasn't the same as kissing Zach. She moved her lips against his eagerly, but she kissed too hard. Kellen pulled back a little to soften the kiss but maintained contact. After a while, he pulled away and looked at her expectantly. Her cheeks were flushed and she was panting a little.

“Wow!” Karin exclaimed. “You're a fantastic kisser!”

“Thanks.”

Karin put her arms around his neck. “What else are you good at?” she breathed as she leaned in for another kiss.

-o-o-o-

Kellen walked home from Karin's house feeling strange. He was tired and satisfied, but it wasn't the same feeling he had when he went home after having sex with Zach. Zach left him feeling fulfilled both physically and emotionally. Sex with Karin satisfied his body, but that was all. He pulled his phone out of his pocket and stared at it. He wanted to call Zach. But Zach had not called him, so he was obviously still busy. Kellen sighed and put the phone away.

“What am I doing?” he muttered to himself. “A girl picks me up and I score, and all I can think about is Zach. I don't understand what's going on.”

-o-o-o-

Karin Hanson dangled off the side of her bed and reached for her purse. She was just able to snag a strap and drag it toward her. She rolled over onto her back with a contented smile as she dug her phone out. She crossed her legs and bounced one foot in the air as she punched a number with her thumb.

“Lisa, guess what?”

“What? This better not be stupid. I'm busy.”

“I just did it with Kellen Tarrow.”

“No way!”

“Way! He just left.”

“Really!” Lisa's exclamation ended in a sharp squeak. “He's such a total hottie! Was he good?”

“Oh yeah, he was great.” Karin rolled over onto her stomach. “I got him to do all kinds of kinky stuff. He really got into it. He made me come twice.”

“Wow! But I heard he was gay. Isn't he supposed to be going out with Zach Kirby?”

“That's the story, but if he is, he fucks pretty good for a gay guy.”

“Wow!” Lisa repeated. “So are you going to start dating him?”

“Maybe, but not exclusively. He's a sweetie, but jocks are always blowing off dates for training and meets and stuff.” Karin paused. “If you're interested in him, go for it. I won't be jealous.”

“Huh. Maybe I'll give him a try. My last boyfriend was useless in bed. He kept saying it was me, but my vibrator never has any trouble satisfying me.” She laughed and Karin laughed too.

“You should give him a try, then. I don't think you'll be disappointed.”

“Thanks. Talk to you later.”

“Bye.” Karin disconnected and stared at the phone for a second. Then she giggled and hopped off the bed to take a shower. Kellen was definitely hot but Karin didn't mind sharing him. There were a lot of hot guys at school and she wasn't ready to settle for just one of them.

-o-o-o-o-o-

The swim coach's emergency turned out not to be too serious. His wife had gotten into a fender-bender, but being a somewhat timid woman by nature, she had been rattled by the accident. But having missed a day of practice with a meet coming up on Thursday, he was anxious for the team to make up the training time, so he pushed them extra hard on Tuesday. Kellen was really tired when they were finally released for the day and he debated whether or not he wanted to stop by Zach's place. But even if they didn't have sex, Kellen like Zach's company, so he decided to go anyway. But as he was leaving campus, a girl on a bicycle stopped him.

“Hi Kellen! Do you remember me? We met at Andrea Caine's party last summer. My name is Lisa Mullens.”

Kellen shifted his backpack and suppressed a sigh as he stopped to face her. “Yes, I remember you.” In fact, he didn't remember her at all, but he suspected she would find that answer insulting.

She stood straddling her bike and smiled brightly at him. “I know this sounds really forward, but I was wondering if you'd like to come over to my house? I made cookies for the food festival on Friday and I have some extra.”

What is this? Kellen wondered. Am I wearing a sign that says “Hit on this guy”? Lisa had that kind of perky cuteness that probably got tiring after a few hours. Her light brown hair was cut in a short pixie style that framed her face and made her look younger than she was. “Thanks for asking, Lisa, but I can't today. I'm pretty wiped from practice and I've got a ton of homework to finish.”

Her lips formed into a cute little pout. “That's ok. Maybe we can get together some other time?” She fixed large brown eyes on him and tipped her head to one side.

“Yeah, maybe next week.”

“Ok! Next week then!” She stepped onto her bike pedals and pushed off. She waved at him with a bright smile as she rode away.

Kellen sighed. Why now? Why are girls coming onto me now? Brett had told him once that most girls just assumed he already had a girlfriend because he was such a hunk and because he never seemed that interested. But the truth was that Kellen, like a lot of guys, was a little shy and leery of rejection, so he had never quite figured out how to approach girls. And now that they were approaching him, he wasn't quite sure how to handle it. Getting laid without having to work for it was certainly pleasant, but still…

Lost in thought, his feet naturally carried him to Zach's house. He came out of his reverie to find himself standing on Zach's front porch. He rang the bell, feeling somewhat apprehensive. Did Zach know about Karin?

When Zach opened the door, his expression was a little odd. “Hey Kellen, you're late.”

“Sorry,” Kellen replied as he stepped inside. “Practice ran late. Coach was trying to make up for yesterday.”

“Oh.” Zach shut the door and headed for the kitchen. “Hungry?”

“No.” Kellen let his backpack slide off his shoulder and caught it in one hand. He followed Zach into the kitchen. The silence felt awkward. “If you're busy, I can come over another time.”

“I'm not busy,” Zach said quickly. He turned toward Kellen. “I just thought maybe you had somewhere else to go.” He kept his eyes on Kellen's face as he spoke. His expression was flat. Kellen couldn't tell what Zach was feeling and he felt his cheeks flushing.

“You heard about Karin.”

“Yeah.” Zach clipped the word off, like he was stopping himself from saying more.

Kellen dropped his eyes. “I think she just wanted to get laid. It didn't mean anything.”

“I see.”

Kellen looked up. Zach was still watching his face with the same flat expression. Kellen was so used to seeing his smile that the expression seemed harsh. It wounded him. It made him want to kiss Zach and apologize for being a jackass, even though he really hadn't done anything. But since he thought of it, he decided to try that approach anyway. He dropped his backpack and stepped forward to rest his hands on Zach's shoulders.

“I'm sorry, Zach. I should have told you I was going to see her. I didn't mean to keep it a secret.” Then he leaned forward and kissed Zach on the lips. Zach didn't respond at first, but then his lips pressed warmly against Kellen's. Kellen slipped his arms around Zach's shoulders and pulled the smaller boy against his chest, holding him close. He caressed Zach's lips with his tongue and then opened his mouth. Zach's tongue probed between his lips, questing eagerly into his mouth. Kellen relaxed into the kiss, feeling comfortable at last. Kissing Zach just felt so right. He felt Zach's growing excitement pressing hard against his thigh and his own cock started getting hard in response. The tiredness from the long practice flowed out of him and was replaced by desire. He pulled his lips away. “Am I forgiven?”

“Don't apologize,” Zach whispered. “It's not like I own you. And I was busy yesterday.”

Kellen smoothed Zach's hair back from his face. He did not understand his feelings. He was deeply attracted to Zach and he was starting to recognize that the attraction was not just physical. He wanted to spend time in Zach's company and he was happiest when they were together. Unable to resist the impulse, he kissed Zach again. “But I'm sorry anyway. I want to make it up to you. Can we go to bed?”

Zach smiled, lighting up his face. “If you want to.”

“I want to.”

They walked to Zach's bedroom holding hands.

“Let me undress you,” Zach said in a sultry voice.

Kellen stood still and let Zach strip him. It was a complete turn-on. Zach undressed him slowly, pausing frequently to kiss and lick Kellen's skin as he exposed it, showing special attention to his nipples. Kellen was panting with desire by the time he was naked, in large part because Zach was now kneeling in front of him, licking the tip of his penis.

“You're driving me crazy!” he rasped.

“Am I?” Zach purred. “Is there something you want?”

“Yes!” Kellen groaned. “I want you to suck me off!”

Zach chuckled warmly. “I think I can manage that.” He stroked his tongue along Kellen's cock in a long, slow, wet caress before sliding his mouth over the now-leaking tip. Kellen's brain immediately shut off so his senses could focus on what was happening to his cock. Zach's technique was shattering. Kellen tangled his fingers in Zach's hair, gasping with pleasure. His legs shook as he thrust his hips forward eagerly, desperate to experience the full measure of Zach's deep throat. Zach worked him relentlessly, driving Kellen quickly over the edge into screaming ecstasy. He came hard, his entire body jerking in response to the explosion of pleasure in his loins.

“Oh!” Kellen gasped. His legs felt like they were going to buckle. Zach released him and he collapsed onto the edge of the bed. “Oh man! That was incredible!”

Zach crawled over and leaned on Kellen's knees with a smile. “It must have been good. You practically drowned me.”

Kellen stroked his fingers through Zach's hair. “My ass is yours, handsome.”

“You think I'm handsome?”

“Yeah.” Kellen grinned. “I do.” He cupped Zach's face in his hands, leaned over and kissed him softly on the mouth. “Now get up here and have your way with me.” Kellen crawled backward onto the bed, turned around and bent over, sticking his butt in the air.

A moment later, Zach climbed onto the bed and rubbed Kellen's bottom affectionately. “This is certainly a most appealing sight.” He kissed Kellen's right buttock. Then he inserted a lube-coated finger into Kellen's anus and Kellen arched his back with a groan. Zach's finger explored him, moving around and encouraging him to open up. After a moment, he added another finger, working the pair in and out while Kellen writhed with excitement. His cock was already hard again. He began to whine eagerly, anxious to feel Zach's cock.

“I want your cock, Zach,” he moaned. “My ass is on fire!”

Zach grasped him by the hips and jammed the tip of his thick cock into Kellen's ass.

“Yeah, do it!” Kellen gasped. “Don't hold back!”

Zach held his hips firmly and pounded into him hard, driving in deeper and deeper with each thrust until his hips were banging against Kellen's ass. Kellen slumped onto his chest, gasping helplessly through his open mouth, his fingers twisting into the blankets. Zach's cock felt incredible. Wave after wave of mind-blowing pleasure wracked his body. Like every other time Zach fucked him, Kellen went wild with pleasure. He bucked and rocked in response to Zach's thrusts, screaming with joy. Orgasm exploded in his loins, bursting off the tip of Zach's jabbing erection.

“Ahh!!!” Kellen collapsed onto his belly, completely unaware of the wetness underneath him.

Zach sprawled on his back, gasping for breath. “Oh god!”

For long, exhausted minutes, they lay unmoving, trying to catch their breath.

“I'm running out of superlatives,” Zach groaned. “I think it's better every time.”

“Yeah,” Kellen moaned. “I don't know how you do it.”

“You inspire me.” Zach rolled off Kellen's back and onto his own to stare up at the ceiling. “You're the best guy I've ever been with.”

Kellen chuckled. “You're the only guy I've ever been with, so I guess that makes you my best, too.” He grinned at Zach. “But I'm not planning on doing any comparison shopping. I don't think it gets any better than you.”

Zach returned his smile. “I'm glad you came over today.”

“So am I.” Kellen pushed up onto his knees with a groan. “But I'm going to hate myself at swim practice tomorrow.”

Zach sat up also. “We probably shouldn't see each other tomorrow or you'll flop at the meet on Thursday.”

“Yeah,” Kellen nodded. He ran his fingers through his hair. “I should take a shower before I go home.” He slid off the bed and walked stiffly to the bathroom. He always ached so much after sex with Zach, but it was such a pleasant ache.

“I'll come to the meet,” Zach said, following him into the bathroom, “but I have to come straight home and cook after that. I have to make the stuff for the food festival on Friday.”

“Oh, right.” Kellen turned on the water and stuck his hand in to wait for it to get hot. “What about after that? Can I spend the night again?”

Zach blinked in surprise. “My folks will be home all weekend.”

“Too bad.” Kellen stepped into the shower wondering why he was so disappointed. Why was spending time with Zach so important to him? The phenomenal sex was clearly a large part of his motivation, but he no longer believed that was the only thing. Kellen stuck his head under the faucet and let the water sluice through his hair and down his back. I don't understand myself. What the hell am I doing?