Yu-Gi-Oh! Fan Fiction ❯ Love Doesn't Have To Be Logical ❯ Chapter 3: The Beginning ( Chapter 3 )

Disclaimer: Come on people, how many times do I have to say this? I don't own Yu-gi-oh! Takahashi-san won't give them to me no matter what. ::frowns:: Oh well, at least we can write about them!

A/N: Konnichiwa everyone. I didn't think that little old cliffhanger would give me such dramatic comments…*smiles innocently* J/K. And since you all wanted to know so bad what Yugi decided…well, here it is in black and white. But first I have some people to thank:

Crazy Yami, Ryu Arashi, Blue September, chibi neko, shadow fire, MysticalElf78, Hermeny, Marl, Preventer Pixie, Iyasu, Yaoi fan, Unconditional Believer, ananda, Jadesaber, Kawaiiskye, PixieDust, Kasianne, Kura, Sakura, Amethyst Sin, Yami's Girl710, Reinara, and especially to those who reviewed more then once. Thank you so much!! Now Yami will do the warnings.

Yami: And why is that? I was just about to cuddle with my aibou! ::glares at Authoress::

Authoress: ::glares back:: You WILL do that warning unless you want Tea stalking you…

Yami: ::gulps:: Ahem, of course… ::turns to audience:: This story will contain yaoi, hints of lemon, some fluff, and a little OOCness. And maybe some swearing if the Authoress decides. Don't like don't read. ::gives audience stone chipping glare, making even the crickets stop chirping:: Wow, I must be scary… ::smirks as he walks off proud of the fact::

Authoress: Um…ok…*sweatdrops* Anyway, don't mind that part…Just go on and do what you came here for…

By the way: /Yugi to Yami/, //Yami to Yugi//

*~* ~ Flashback *~*~

"Yugi, hey it's me. What's up?" He replied, happy to hear from the younger boy.

"Well, you told me to call if I decided…Did I catch you at a…bad time…?" His tone was uneasy, but Yami figured it was only nervousness.

"No, no, we weren't doing much don't worry." He smiled, "Did you come to a decision yet Hikari?"

Through their link he felt Yugi's emotions mixing, but was quiet as the boy breathed softly. He had a feeling he was trembling just slightly on the other end.

"Yeah, I did Yami…I decided that…"

* * *

"I decided that…I would like to give it a try…As long as you're willing to deal with my inexperience…" Yugi told his darker half, huddling closer into his pillow. He was extremely nervous, but his trembling had thankfully started to cease.

"Seto and I have no problem with that. Being with someone inexperienced can be a lot of fun…" Yami said, smiling widely. He was so glad Yugi had decided on yes. He really cared for his Hikari, and he knew of his sadness and loneliness. Even being so far away Yami could still feel his emotions. He was surprised Seto had come to agree with it, but hey, Yugi isn't hard to love after all.

"Ok…so what happens now…?" The youth asked, completely dumfounded as to how such a relationship worked.

"We take it from the top, nice and slow…Seto and I will arrange a date for tomorrow. I'll be home in a little bit and I'll tell you anything I know." He looked at Seto, who was busy, finishing up some emails on his laptop and wasn't really listening. He could take care of that though.

"Ok…I guess I'll see you later then." Yugi pulled his knees to his chest and wrapped an arm around them.

"I guess you will." Yami smiled, feeling Yugi's pulse quicken at the sound of his voice. "Until then so long mitsukai."

Yugi smiled; no one had ever called him that before. "Bye Yami. And tell Seto I said good night when you leave."

"Will do. Bye." He heard the click on the other line and hung up the phone. Walking coolly over to Seto despite his excitement, he tapped his shoulder. The brunette looked up at him as he sent the last email and stood up from his chair.

"Well…" He was anxious to hear.

Yami stood there calmly for a moment, a totally expressionless face before he said, "He decided to do it."

The taller boy's eyes widened, quite a foreign look on his usual gruff face. Then he smiled, "That's great. Now this is definitely going to get interesting."

Yami chuckled as the two lovers exchanged a high five, chanting as they spun around the room, "We're gonna have a threesome. We're gonna have a threesome…" (A/N: I am SO trying to picture this…o.O)

Seto encircled Yami's waist as he lifted him into the air, spinning in a circle again, "So Yami, I distinctly recall you saying we were to arrange a date…" The Pharaoh smiled as he wrapped his arm's around his neck.

"Yeah, we said we were gonna take it slow after all. We should go on a date with him tomorrow, give him an idea of what it's like. But where?" He asked, still hugging his neck as the CEO took a seat on the bed, holding Yami in his lap.

"Sounds like a good idea. How about we catch a movie and then go to dinner at that new Chinese restaurant, The Golden Buffet? I've been wanting to try that." He replied.

"Sounds good to me. What movie should we see though? I think something romantic…" Yami quirked his eyebrows suggestively. Seto chuckled as he hugged him tighter,

"You bad bad boy. Get your mind out of the gutter." He punched him playfully on the head. Yami smiled with fake innocence, "What's so bad about that? We do it all the time and Yugi doesn't know what he's missing." Seto rolled his eyes,

"I swear sometimes you and your girlish manner frighten me Yami." The Pharaoh stuck his tongue out at him, "Like you and your two faced demeanor isn't any less normal?"

He looked like he was going to say something back but just waved his hand at him, "Ah whatever. If romantic is what you want then fine. You two decide; just don't pick on a sappy Lifetime drama. I'll make reservations for dinner."

Yami kissed his cheek, "All right sounds like a date. I'll tell Yugi when I get home."

"You might have to wait till morning Yami." He raised a brow, "Why do you say that?"

"Because I was planning on celebrating…" With an evil grin, he threw Yami further onto the bed and pounced, pinning the Pharaoh to the mattress as he advanced.

* * *

Yugi sighed softly before yawning as he stretched lazily on his bed. He turned to gaze at the moon lighted window. It was already 11:30 and Yami wasn't back yet. He said he was coming home. Did he and Seto lose track of time or did something happen? Yugi shook his head hard as he forced back the worry struggling to creep in. He began to think about today.

When Yami and him had talked at the Java Shop, he had never expected his other half to inquire something of the sort from him. But when he returned home and thought about it, it seemed to make sense. The strange looks, the flirtatious attitude…Not to mention just the unusual vibes received. But still, even with his crush on the Pharaoh he was hesitant about agreeing. After all, a threesome was much more different then a two way. Not that he'd have any problem with Seto. When deciding he wondered if the idea of another would make him jealous, but then he realized Seto was a pretty important person to him, and he could learn to love him as well.

So after a long period of careful consideration, he decided it might be okay to give it a try. After all, Yami and Seto wouldn't push him. He knew that; it was just the early stage stuff that kinda made him nervous at the moment. After all he was so inexperienced for his age, but it seemed Yami and Seto favored the fact he was innocent. As for the later stages…well, he decided to worry about that when the time came.

Just as he began to wonder where Yami was for the hundredth time, he heard the sounds of the front door moving downstairs. Sitting up in bed, his ears took in the soft footsteps padding quietly up the stairs. With baited breath he stared as his door was softly pushed open.

After turning on the lamp next to his bed, he realized who the figure was, "Yami, you're back. Thank Kami I was wondering where you were." He smiled.

The dark one nodded with a sincere smile as he trotted forward, sitting on Yugi's bed next to him. "Sorry I'm late Yugi. Seto and I kinda lost track of time…" Yugi then noticed Yami's clothes were a bit wrinkled and his hair was messy.

"I can see why…" The youth quipped, earning a smirk from his older half. "That's ok though, you're home now. So what's up?"

Yami shrugged, "Nothing much. Seto and I decided the three of us should go check out a movie then go to dinner at that new Chinese restaurant, The Golden Buffet."

Yugi offered a small smile, "That sounds good, what movie though?" He tilted his head like a curious kitten. Yami couldn't help but adore the cute look it created (A/N: Awww!)

"I don't know. We'll check the paper tomorrow and see. Seto said he doesn't care as long as it's no major sappy chick flick." Yugi laughed softly, "He's crazy, but that's all right I guess."

"I know. But hey that's the way it works. And I'm sorry if I worried you aibou." He brushed some of Yugi's yellow bangs away from his orbs.

"Don't worry about it. I was a little concerned but I figured nothing was happening; or else I would have felt it in our link. Right now you seem tired."

The Pharaoh shrugged, "A little. I'm not fragile china though so I'll be fine." He scooted a little closer, and Yugi began to feel fidgety. Yami noticed this and slowly, almost assuringly, put an arm around him to gently pull his smaller body to him. As soon as Yugi's head touched his shoulder he wrapped another arm around his waist, settling him into his lap, savoring the feel of the small angel in his arms.

Yugi swallowed a forming lump in his throat as he settled into the embrace. Don't get nervous, He thought, Don't get nervous…This is Yami after all…he won't do anything…but why do I feel so tense?

Yami could feel the anxiety churning over Yugi's aura. Concentrating he sensed the increased pace of the young one's heart. Grinding his cheek softly into the boys' hair, he whispered,

"You all right?" His tone was concerned.

Yugi placed a hand on his chest in an awkward manner, the feel so faint that it almost seemed he wasn't touching him. He wrapped his free arm around the taller one, before replying in a voice trying to avoid shakiness, "Yeah, I'm all right…just a bit nervous…"

Although he wasn't looking Yami gazed down from his spot with sympathy. Holding the boy tighter, he began to rock him back and forth in gentle assuring motions.

"Don't be nervous Yugi…It might seem weird at first but it'll get better with time I promise…Just relax.." Within a few moments he felt the tension start to cease and Yugi released a soft breath, one that meant he was beginning to relax in the embrace.

He's right…It isn't that bad once you get used to it…I've always dreamt of him holding me like this…And now he is…It just seems too good to be true…

Yami slowed his motions some but kept them going as he and Yugi sat there in new silence, enjoying being in each other's arms. How good it felt to hold him. His body was so soft…not that he started to dislike the feel of hugging Seto; Yugi was just different. Three really can be a charm.

Yugi closed his eyes in content. He had always felt secure with Yami; the spirit was always more confident and fearless when it came to situations like these. Well, just about any situation really…Yami had tried to make Yugi more self-confident, but he only succeeded a little. Yugi was still quite modest, not to mention body shy. Yami discovered that when he accidentally walked in the bathroom one day and Yugi had just stepped out of the shower, a small towel around his waist. As soon as he saw Yami in the door way, his face lost its color and he bolted out of there like a bat out of hell and locked himself in his room. Yami had laughed about it then, especially when Yugi had trouble looking at him and kept blushing. He still laughed when he thought about it. He had never met someone so innocent and shy.

Just then Yugi felt Yami shift his arms around him. He opened his eyes but didn't look up, for the Pharaoh had his head firmly locked under his jaw. Yugi was now fully curled up against Yami's body, and he never felt so safe and warm. Suddenly, Yami lifted his chin and pressed a light kiss to Yugi's head. He felt the smaller one quirk at the touch, but nothing more. Pulling back, he lifted Yugi's head and their gazes locked. How he loved Yugi's eyes. They never bothered to hide his purity and emotions. Such beautiful amethyst color…And they were wider and gentler then any other he had seen.

Yugi felt his breath cut off as he and Yami stared. The darker one's eyes were so damn alluring…So much different from his own. Just as he felt himself about to be completely lost in the crimson vision, Yami leaned down slowly, almost in millimeters. Titling the boy's head back, he gently pressed their lips together. Just a brief touch. Their eyes closed and Yami parted his lips with his tongue, kissing him fully now but still with gentleness. His lips were softer and sweeter then they looked. Smooth like a Sakura petal yet fluffy like marshmallows. And the taste…it was like a warm mix of vanilla and cinnamon.

Yugi made a little noise in the back of his throat as Yami deepened the kiss, their lips coming in contact harder. This was his first kiss, he felt sort of lightheaded and it felt as if his heart had stopped. He gasped when Yami suddenly snaked his tongue past his lips, the velvety wet surface exploring his mouth. Yami felt like he was in heaven. As they continued he met Yugi's own shy tongue to gain dominance over it. He mentally smiled to himself and kissed him harder, cupping his face gently with his hands. Yugi grasped Yami's shoulders, feeling like he was going to lose balance and fall back on the bed. It was as if his insides were melting because he was so warm.

The hand holding Yugi's right cheek now moved itself so it latched on just below Yugi's opposite shoulder, the other going back around his waist. Yami had never enjoyed such a moment. Yugi tasted wonderful, and he was just heaven to hold. He couldn't believe Seto and him hadn't thought of this sooner. Getting lost in the goodness he pulled Yugi and himself away from the edge. Yugi remained curled up while the Pharaoh stretched his legs. He kissed him much slower now, allowing the youth to breathe through his nose. Pulling away just slightly a few moments later he parted his lids to stare at Yugi's face.

His eyes were still closed, but he looked so beautiful still. His pale cheeks now mixed with a delicate red; lips still parted for he and Yami were still kissing softly. Pressing his mouth harder again, he removed his hands to run them over the young boy's body, loving the feel of his smooth moist skin. He began to feel himself growing hard and without rethinking, pushed on Yugi till he was back on the bed, Yami pinning him down gently. The Pharaoh groaned happily as he twirled some of Yugi's hair with his fingers.

Yugi on the other hand was starting to grow a little scared at the close encounter. He knew how sex happened, well, he knew with a girl anyway…He wasn't completely sure how two guys did it but knew since Yami and Seto started dating it was possible. Ryou had told him once when Yugi had asked a little about it that the first time always hurt; after that it could be the next few or none at all. It all matters on the person he said. Yugi had pondered about it but didn't have enough guts to ask much more. And he was definitely too embarrassed to ask Yami.

He broke out of his thoughts as he felt Yami's large hands exploring his body again, only growing dangerously closer to certain areas that were left undisturbed. His heart quickening, this time in anxiety, he attempted at stopping Yami as soon as he had pulled his lips back.

"Yami…we should stop…I…I can't go any further…" He was really starting to get nervous now; Yami on the other hand breathed heavily in his ear, pressing down a little harder on Yugi.

"Ssh relax Hikari…it'll be all right…" He seemed overrode by lust and started to move his hands down to push them up under Yugi's shirt.

"Yami." The shorter boy's brain was beginning to go into panic mode, and he started squirming under the Pharaoh's superior weight. How could Yami want more after already being with Seto?

"Oh Yugi…" The statement came out in a growl, and he felt Yami caressing his skin, the pressure growing firmer with each massage. He closed his eyes and while trying to resist without going crazy on the taller one on top of him, Ryou's words kept ringing in his head for some reason.

It always hurts the first time…Whether a little after that or none at all is up to the person's endurance…

Yugi's eyes snapped open as he replayed those words slowly. It always hurts…It always hurts…

Now in a full panic, he shot his arms forward and pushed at Yami's chest. "Stop!" For being so small and weak he showed quite a bit of strength in that push. As soon as Yami was off him he scooted back and huddled into the wall, bringing his knees up and staring at his dark with deer eyes, embracing his legs.

Yami caught his breath in a few gasps, staring at his light cowering away from him. What had he been thinking? He was still a virgin after all! And he knew how innocent Yugi was. He mentally punched himself, Damnit I said I was gonna take it slow now look what I'm doing! Yugi's probably in a total panic.

As they stared for a few minutes, he took in the wide frightened look in the boy's purple eyes. He had to get to Yugi, to reassure him, make him feel comfortable again.

"Yugi…I'm so sorry. I don't know what I was thinking…" He crawled forward, noting how Yugi started to tense at his approach. Slowly, he moved till he reached the young one, holding him close as he tried to comfort him.

"There there Hikari, it's all right. I won't do anything you don't want me to do I swear to Ra. I let my hormones get the best of me…" Squeezing him just a bit, he sighed with relief as he felt Yugi gradually ease again.

"I'm sorry Yami…I just got scared…" Before he could continue apologizing, the spirit put a finger to his lips, silencing him.

"Don't be sorry Hikari. If anyone should be it's me. I understand you got scared, and I shouldn't have gone so far. I promise to act better next time." He kissed the boys cheek, the smooth skin leaving a tingle on his lips. Yugi looked at him, no longer scared,

"It's ok Yami. You didn't get too far so need to worry. Just be sure to control your hormones." He smiled cutely, earning a laugh from the Pharaoh.

"I swear on my Dueling Deck I will be more smart next time. Right now we should probably get some sleep." As if on cue Yugi yawned, Yami doing so afterwards, only his was deeper.

"Yeah I guess your right. Well good night Yami." He hugged Yami softly, who returned it just the same.

"Sweet dreams little light. Seto said good night as well." Pulling back he relished the happy glow on Yugi's angelic face. God how virtuous he looked…So pure…Kissing him gently he climbed off the bed and left Yugi's room, smiling his smile before he left. Yugi sat there for a moment, taking in all that just happened. Yami had kissed him. Actually kissed him! His first kiss…It was better then he had ever imagined. Feeling the heat in his face he brought a hand to his lips, smiling as he brought it down.

Settling under the covers, he sighed contently as he took one last look at the bright stars gleaming from his window. It was as if they were grinning, celebrating Yugi's happiness. Closing his eyes he slept peacefully through the night, the sweet smile never leaving his face.

* * *

//Aibou, are you almost done? Seto and I are only a few blocks away from the Game Shop. //

/Yeah, I just need to brush my hair. I'll jump out the window into the car if I have to. /

//Don't do that or you'll mess up your hair, not to mention break a few bones. // Yami laughed.

/Oh…be quiet and let me finish getting ready. /

//Whatever you wish. // He felt Yami's connection close off then.

Tomorrow had come rather quickly for the three. It was about quarter to six, and they were getting ready to go to the movies. Well, Yugi was anyway. Yami had been at Seto's all afternoon and had left with him to come pick up Yugi. The youth was shaking with nervousness. This was to be their first date. He still couldn't fully believe this was happening.

Maybe once I get used to being around both of them it won't be so nerve racking. Otherwise I'm gonna need some tranquilizer every time we go out.

Pulling the brush through his thick, soft hair one last time, he walked over to the full-length mirror on his closet door for a quick check over of his hair and clothes. He had spent nearly two hours going through his closet and dresser, trying to find the appriopate thing to wear. Finally he chose on a pair of dark blue pants, his white and black sneakers, and a long sleeved black shirt with a light gray vest over it. His shirt and pants were a bit snugger but still hung around his small form. And of course he had his Millennium Puzzle on a thick black and silver entwined thread.

Sighing, he hurried down the stairs to wait impatiently in the living room. He was glad his Grandpa was out getting some supplies for the store; or else he would have had to answer a million questions about where he was going and such. They still hadn't decided what to do about telling him and all. Then again they hadn't talked about it yet.

Pacing around the living room trying to keep calm, he thought about the date approaching. Two guys, not one, Two guys to love, to get close to. It was definitely going to be a new experience for the young boy.

Just then he heard the doorbell ring. Briskly strolling to the door he opened it to find Yami standing there. Seto was in his own car, a black Alero, sitting behind the wheel waiting.

"Hey, been waiting long?" Yugi thought he looked so desirable, his leather pants skintight as usual. Only instead of the sleeveless shirt he wore his "IF I HAD A MILLION DOLLARS…" T-shirt from America and authentic dark leather boots. Sniffing the air Yugi noticed he also had put on some minted cologne and a short spiked leather bracelet lay wrapped around his left wrist.

"No, just a few minutes. You look good Yami." He was surprised he had the bravery to say so.

"Thanks. You look pretty damn good yourself beautiful." He winked at the youth, who blushed deeply at the compliment. Laughing he gently grasped his hand and pulled him out the door, Yugi turning around in time to shut it as Yami pulled him toward the car.

"Oh I almost forgot. Seto and I bought these for you." Lifting his wrist covered arm he held a small but beautiful bouquet of flowers, bright and dark colors of roses, lilacs, jasmines (A/N: Are they flowers?) daises, and other miscellaneous plants.

"For me?" He looked at him as if he was dreaming. The taller one nodded, smiling. "Thank you Yami, they're beautiful." He took them gratefully, sniffing in the wonderful mix of fragrances.

"A beautiful person deserves beautiful flowers." Holding back the chuckle at the red in Yugi's shy face, he opened the door for him.

"Thanks." Yugi told him as he slid quietly in the back, feeling the first time nervousness crawl back in him again.

Seconds later Yami was back in the passengers seat up front. Right before Seto started the car back up to full acceleration he turned to look at Yugi.

"Hey Yugi how's it going?" It was then that the tri colored angel noticed how intoxicating the CEO's smile was. And his sapphire blue eyes shone with a quiet but glamorous spell.

"It's been good. Thank you for the flowers." He looked down at the bouquet before continuing, "How about you?" For some reason his thighs went together and he softly grasped the fabric over his knees.

"Your welcome, and I'm good. You look nervous." Yugi shrugged.

"I guess I am a little."

"A little is an understatement." Yami quipped, the look he sent indicating he knew Yugi was lying.

"I swear I'm gonna find a way to block you out of my emotions even if it kills me." The two laughed.

"At least wait till we go to dinner. I'd be wasting money on an extra person who's not there." Seto ordered. Chuckling he turned back around and got the car into gear.

//Yugi. //

/Yeah? /

//Don't be so shaky. It'll be fun. //

/I know Yami. I just can't help it. /

//You'll be laughing at this by the end of the night. //

/Whatever you say Yami. /

With the end of their private conversation, Seto hit the gas and they were off to the movies for their first date as a threesome.

* * *

A/N: Oh Praise the Lord I'm done! ::grabs Yami and does a victory dance:: I was soooo desperate to get that done. And I knew you all wanted to read it. I'm sorry it took me so long. I was going to get it out by the weekend but I couldn't write the rest. Well ::stops dancing with Yami who staggers off to Seto and Yugi:: Next chapter is their date. The more reviews the more chance of getting it faster. Thank you! ^_^

And for those of you wondering this, mitsukai means "My angel"